Fool me Once, Shame on me; or, the NFB shoved me back to high school

The NFB, dedicated to bringing Blind people together, has managed to make me feel so much more alone.

a paper hanging on a wooden peg with a white can crudely drawn on it. underneath is written "My white cane let's me go anywhere. Canes rule."
I drew a picture for an exhibit at the Walker Art Center. Ignore my typo please.

I have not felt ashamed of my Blindness in nearly half a decade. Attending my first National Federation of the Blind convention made me feel ashamed of being Blind. I’m known for dramatic statements and I’m definitely known for being more than willing to burn bridges that very likely could help me in the future, but even I give pause to this particular introduction. Do I want to throw a gauntlet at the United States’ “premier” Blind advocacy group? Do I want to run the risk of a potential employer seeing this essay and dashing my ambitions upon the rock because I took jabs at the membership they cherish? Do I want to start public beef with a subsection of my own community in a socio-political climate where infighting should be the last thing us marginalised folks should be doing?

First thing you need to know is that the National Federation of the Blind (NFB from here on out) is dogmatic above all else. They want to present as a unified front of Blind opinion and so any dissent shown towards ideas upheld by the leadership is met with intense dismissal. There is no room for debate, and anyone who doesn’t agree with what leadership is presenting as the collective’s paradigm is conditioned into shrugging it off. The big ticket item at the Minnesota state convention I attended was a proposed opposition to a Minnesota law that would ban driverless vehicles in the state. NFB leadership argues that driverless cars offer a ride share experience that has less potential for discrimination as human drivers frequently illegally deny guide dogs rides in their car.

While I can understand the base instinct behind the decision, I think we shouldn’t trust the tech companies behind driverless ride share vehicles to have anyone’s interests in mind but their own. During the meeting where the members discussed this issue and whether or not we should pass it along to the national chapter to ratify as a collective NFB goal, I was the only one to voice dissent. Which caused audible shock in many other NFB members in the room. It felt like they’d never heard of anyone dare go against the wishes of the general leadership. I’d also like to note that I was the only person that the president of the Minnesota chapter had a response for. A response that was nothing more than a complete argument against and dismissal of my general opinion. I talked to a few folks who were quiet during the meeting and they, too, weren’t too keen on the idea of driverless ride shares taking to the streets, but they told me that it “wasn’t worth it” to argue against it. A response that chilled me considering this came from someone who was himself a seasoned and well-positioned member of the Minnesota NFB.

The NFB, we must remember, is the Blind organisation that argued against making United States currency tactile and more accessible to Blind folks. This is the organisation that argued against the beeping cross walk buttons. Their reasoning is that Blind people should get absolutely no preferential treatment, that we should rely solely on our training and endure things being harder for the sake of….pride? Smug satisfaction? Their reasoning, if mirrored by strong advocates from our past, would see us telling wheelchair users that they don’t need curb cuts as they should have the strength to push their wheels up curbs. They forget that the curb cut effect is a powerful tool in our society and that every time they argue against accessibility for the sake of their pride, they are advocating against what could be a life-changing tool for a group that had no idea they needed tactile paper money or beeping cross walks.

Which is all to say, that they don’t have a great history of choosing well for the Blind community and their tendency to present themselves as the Blind advocacy group is potentially dragging our cause back by years. Their dogmatic united front attitude, wherein dissent is quickly silenced, also gives it a power structure that leads to things like the rampant racism and sexual violence that happens at NFB conventions and institutions. They, of course, investigated and shuffled some people around and rewrote some laws, but many of the perpetrators of those crimes walk free and, anecdotally, the NFB never reformed the structures that enabled such an environment. The leadership of the Minnesota chapter seemed, to me, to be far too comfortable with their authority. They were arrogant in all they did, and positioned themselves constantly apart from the general crowd. Perpetuating this power structure is exactly how you tell people that there is a higher class than you in your organisation and that they can do whatever they wish.

During the banquet on the penultimate night, an event billed as the thing not to miss, the president proudly proclaimed that there was not a VIP table, as everyone in the room was an equal, but instead there was a “harvest table,” where distinguished guests and chapter leadership would sit and have a special introduction given to them.

That’s a fucking VIP table dressed in a pumpkin spice latte of a coat.

I also noticed a distinct lack of intersectional awareness in some of the other members. We were sat with the director of the Minnesota State Services for the Blind (SSB) giving her feedback on some upcoming rule changes. She was lovely to chat with, I have to say, and I can’t help but attribute said loveliness to her lack of membership in the Federation. An old woman in the back of the feedback session room talked about a lengthy test SSB used to give to determine the skills and tendencies of applicants to better match them in a job. She ruefully reflected on a young woman she’d known who had ADHD or some trouble concentrating, the old woman couldn’t specifically recall which, and how this young woman wanted to be a surgeon. The old woman was appalled at such an ambition and claimed that someone with such trouble concentrating could never be a surgeon! And that a length evaluation given at the onset of services could have cautioned against such a career.

I’m fucking sorry, but what?! A top member of a group that is dedicated to claiming Blind people can do fucking anything is telling folks with ADHD that they can’t be surgeons? The directed of SSB shot the woman down, thank heavens, but her testimony got a lot of agreement from the crowd. That we should be screening for such disconnects instead of letting people work towards careers using tools they develop with the help of experts and their community.

This is another expression of that dogmatic tendency. The NFB is of the blind and most certainly not of anyone else. Blind people can do anything, but everyone else has clear limitations brought upon them by the divine creator.

Which they prayed to before the main course of the earlier banquet. Now, Blind folks may not be a wholly united front, a healthy disposition to have, but one thing most disabled people can get behind is our hatred of being prayed over and our absolute denial of out accomplishments and survival being credited to God. So tell me why the opening banquet prayer did both? Tell me why anyone allowed someone to construct a prayer in which the great achievements of the Blind community and our individual persistence is given to the glory of the Christian God? A Blind woman gave the prayer! To a room of Blind people wherein the only dissenting voice was, once again, mine. I was already confounded at the prayer to begin with, as far as I know the NFB is not an overtly religious organisation, but slapping in one of the few sins disabled people hold inalienable is disgraceful for an organisation that takes such a prescriptive view of pride.

Cultural geography lesson. If you want to plop a collection of disabled people in a city with a robust public transportation network, how far from said transportation network should the chosen hosting hotel be? If your answer is down town where there is plentiful access to both the culture of the city as well as the robust transportation network so that members can enjoy their time in said city and plan excursions out of their mildly okay hotel then you’re fucking dumb and wrong and need to go wipe your ass again. The answer, which is so obvious when you think about it, is to put them all in a hotel in the middle of fuckass no where alongside a loud highway where the nearest bus stop is a twenty minute walk and the only culture anyone will be getting is the empty field that plays host to the signs telling you what the population of Saint Paul is.

Was the planning committee for the conference composed of people who feel that disabled people should be neither seen nor heard nor able to experience joy in any meaningful way? Just strand us all in the middle of no where so that the tantalising experiences of Saint Paul and Minneapolis are arguably within reach but functionally inaccessible to us all.

All of this I can levy against the NFB and not necessarily feel shame. I am not the NFB, the NFB is not me. Why should I feel ashamed of my Blindness just because the largest collection of Blind people in the United States (citation needed) is dismally representing our community?

Oh, yea, there it is.

Paired with that were some of the “panels” that I endured. One that I hope to forget was a panel on employment skills where two employed Blind people were interviewed about their jobs and what skills they’ve developed to better succeed in their jobs as Blind people. Truly, it was riveting stuff. When asked tips on how Blind folks should get a job, an old man who works at a stadium said, “Well, I called the HR and they said to fill out an application online and I did. Then I hoped for an interview and got it and tried my best. Then I waited to see if I got the job and I got it.”

Pay attention folks, there’s a sagely cripple working in Minnesota who knows the secrets to getting a job!

We also got such beloved hits as: organisation, time management, communication, and talking on the phone. You know, skills for Blind people, by Blind people.

There is, of course, so much more. The constant auctions and sales which were loud manifestations of the president’s constant call for more donors and more money; the many interactions that just left a foul taste in my mouth; the sad collection of “vendors” that was really just two state government booths, two Braille display booths, an old man with a beeping dart board, a guide dog association, and then a really fucking cool sexual health and awareness display with wicked neat tactile representations of cocks and balls and vulvas and ovaries and menstruation products and condoms and fetuses and tactile gay pride flags representing everything from lesbian to niche as heck sexualities.

I declined to enter the essay contest as it would clearly just be unfair to everyone else (and I categorically detested their prompt), but I sat at the table with three college students, one of them being the winner of said essay contest. She was handed a wad of bills, we applauded, and then she sat down and we moved on. What, I ask you, is missing? A reading! There was plenty of time for a reading, she deserved a reading, I wanted to hear the winning essay read by the author. But between taunting challenges to increase our monthly donation to the Federation’s coffers and giving bespoke introductions to everyone at the not-VIP table, there was just no time to read a sub-2000 word essay from the contest winner.

I couldn’t help but think of the future of the NFB. Listening around the convention, I was one of the youngest people there. The only ones younger were the three college students, who showed up for the banquet where scholarships and essay prizes were distributed; the Blind children of Blind parents, who probably had to be there; and then ill-behaved and poorly parented sighted children of Blind parents, who ran amok and presented a racist “skit” before the costume contest. I jest not, it was a five minute racist skit put on by a troupe of sighted children and the entire room clapped for it. I went down to the hotel bar. The future, as I heard it there, is not compelling for the NFB. There were no young people there, likely because there was nothing there for them. One of the top-billed and advertised sessions was death planning, a topic that those who are sub-thirty always take interest in.

They distribute scholarships and they have their schools in a few states and there will always be a cohort of young people drawn in by sheer lack of options for finding Blind comrades. The NFB has the schools and the marketing and the plugs with specialists. Their primary competitor, the American Council of the Blind, was born from intense disagreements between NFB leadership and several fed up members. They have resources, sure, but I’ve not heard of them offering free white canes nor have I found anything suggesting they run schools for the Blind like the NFB does. The NFB positions itself to be the first organisation many Blind youth will encounter and that chills me. That tells me that the NFB chews them up, takes their money, and then alienates them in such a way that they don’t return to affect change in the organisation. Probably because the NFB is not organised to take change and is founded on being a monolith of Blind culture.

I haven’t been to the national NFB convention and it’s possible that many of my grievances are alleviated by a larger sample size, but I’m also not willing to take that risk. I paid my five dollars for membership, paid some more to attend the state conference, and I got sent a neat coin and a certificate of membership that I hid behind my degree. I’ll keep the coin, continue hiding the certificate, and never give the NFB money again. I’m done with them and I’m not willing to see if a larger sample size proves to be a salve to my burns. I’m hesitant even to check out the American Council of the Blind, even with their history of fighting the NFB and their more dispersed government style. The NFB, dedicated to bringing Blind people together, has managed to make me feel so much more alone. Gun shy of any organisation claiming to be representative of my needs and nervous to seek out alternative communities for fear that I will find such dogma again.

I kept joking that I was going down to Saint Paul fully prepared to be banned for my dissonance with advertised Federation stances. I think the Minnesota chapter president would like to and I’m sure he has no qualms knowing that he is partially responsible for alienating me from the NFB, but really I was hoping that I would arrive and be surprised. Surprised to find a vibrant, supportive community of Blind comrades who welcome discourse and show me aspects of Blindness that I hadn’t explored before. I can’t say I’m disappointed, as I never hoped for that, just hoped for surprise, but somewhere a monkey paw curled and I did get a shock. An intimate look into an organisation designed to abuse its members and hiding behind Blindness as a way to defer criticism into a stalemate with ableism. I am surprised because I expected something somewhat poor, and got something intensely terrible. The National Federation of the Blind upholds paradigms that they claim to fight against, and it’s all by design. And for a few days, I was once again ashamed to be Blind.


Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to C Somnus McGill.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.